The Genre-based approach was pioneered in Australia (White
et al., 2015, p. 258) and its progress can now be documented into the field of
English as a Foreign Language teaching systems in other countries. In the
Australian context Derewianka (1992, p. 1), describes the type of language
underpinning the syllabus as “functional” which “recognises the relationship
between text and context”. This described the English K-6 Syllabus in 1992 but
is still relevant to the Australian Curriculum brought in in 2014, which has
been “strongly influenced by [SFL] precepts” (White et al., 2015, p. 258). Listed
genres for Stage 4 and 5, in the secondary context, are “Fiction, Poetry, Film,
Nonfiction, Drama” (Board of Studies, 2012, p. 25-26) as well as “spoken texts,
print texts, visual texts, media, multimedia and digital texts” and other more
specific text types such as “picture books and graphic novels” (p. 26). One
fundamental Objective that applies from Early Stage 1 through the end of Stage
6 is “B. use language to shape and make meaning according to purpose, audience
and context” (BOSTES, 2012, p. 15). This objective requires students to compose
texts which adhere to the textual conventions of specific genres and to
consider the context in which they read and write. Riley and Reedy (2000 in Deng,
Chen and Zhang, 2014, p. 28) recognise that “the relationship between purpose,
audience, and linguistic choice involved in the formation of any text…
constitutes the centre of genre-based pedagogy”.
Kongpetch (2003) and Payaprom (2012), assess the applications
of a genre-based approach in the Thai EFL context. Both studies note the
dominance of a more traditional, structural approach to teaching English and
recognise the need to enhance students’ experience of interacting with and
experiencing texts that they will encounter in academic or other real world
contexts. A downfall of the focus on structural grammar for Kongpetch (2003, p.
x) is the focus on increasing students’ spoken proficiency at the expense of
composing complex written texts. Payaprom (2012, p. viii) however, describes a
vision for the genre-based approach to help students “develop an analytical
appreciation of texts” which is required for achievement both in Thailand and
other western contexts of education and industry.
Deng, Chen and Zhang (2014) examine the genre based approach
in the EFL context in China. They note the breadth of literature describing the
“acquisition of textual competence” (p. 1) but the significant gap in research
around “generic competence” (p. 1). Their research targets a “process genre
approach” (p. 10) which encourages students to focus on “purpose and form of
one genre as they undergo the recursive processes of prewriting, drafting,
revision, and editing” (p. 10). Yi (in Ling, Ho, Meyer, Varaprasad and Young,
2003, p. xiv) highlights the importance of English competency for
administrative and academic achievement in Singapore and China and that many
students educated within a structural grammar framework in school EFL programs
are “strong in grammar but very weak in … writing continuous prose”. The approaches
outlined in this research from an intensive English centre in Singapore
resemble a genre based approach in encouraging students to use learning
diaries, emails and children’s literature to improve their competency in spoken
and written English.
No comments:
Post a Comment